The scourge of forced psychiatric hospital admitted

 The scourge of forced psychiatric
treated two psychiatric hospitals of Guangzhou-Shenzhen high income Name: [depth] is the source: [Nanfang Daily] User Comments: 10
sent to mental hospital the previous year, October 3, 2005, Zou Yijun Xiao Meisha play in Shenzhen. Huangxue Tao / courtesy
March 2 this year, Zou Yijun case in Guangzhou Baiyun District Court. intern reporter Fanzhou Bo Liu aspiring taken after discharge from hospital in Guangzhou million
rich He Jinrong.
through Lake Hospital of Zhongshan Port of female mental patients after bath scenario is this: thirty or forty women, naked to squeeze in a large iron gate door, shouting to them to get clothes to health care. big iron gates outside, male health care people walking through the ward, office, corridor, many people staring at their bodies, some male patients is to see your fill before Coushang.
As a male hospitals also suffer the same embarrassment. in the hospital view, a mental patient is almost no physical privacy.
Nevertheless, both are still Hejin Rong Yi Zou, they have a lot of evidence to prove that he did not suffer from mental illness, and psychiatric hospitals based solely on these two statement of their families, forced them admitted. They believe they are not crazy, but no mental health legislation mental patients admitted to institutional constraints.
3 on 2 and 11, Zou and He Jinrong case should have, respectively, in the case Guangzhou Baiyun District Court and the Liwan district court, was criticized for many years of mental disorder were treated once again aroused strong concern.
admitted confusion procedures
law, suspected mental patient must be declared before the court to send governance, But in reality, most of the directly admitted to the hospital, even after a first visit, citing concerns about delays in treatment time
2006 年 10 月 21 morning, Zou Yi were not the now well-known activist nun, her long hair, handsome looks, sitting Zou Jianxiong car older brother, to honor the father of Shenzhen Baoshan cemetery.
reach the cemetery, the Zou Jianxiong out of the car, a van from the side down seven or eight men, will Zou should have pulled out. Zou said that they claimed to the police, but no warrant, no police uniforms.
Zou Yi were forced to wear their van, handcuffed handcuffs back, eyes were kept up an old tie, head sets, a paper bag. Then, two men Paxia her pants and forced, her hips rolling in a shot, after which she so weak.
About an hour later, she was transferred to an ambulance, and was sent to Guangzhou Baiyun Mental Hospital, which is a psychiatric hospital.
another phone to the Shenzhen Lawyers Huang Xuetao secretly made a call. After Huangxue Tao Zou should have started the rescue work.
Since then, she also began admitted to our system of mental patients. She found that the regulations, relatives or other interested parties if the compulsory treatment of mental patients sent to, must apply to the court by the court to declare. And the general view is that the medical profession, mental illness identified needs 3 to 6 months, so may delay the treatment of mental patients time.
So, in the end of the first diagnosed and then treated, or should be diagnosed and then treated it?
reality is that most of the suspected patients were sent directly to the spirit of governance, almost no program at all. such a serious hazard that is, by family members or guardians strict custody, if necessary, by the government to force health care.
2001 年 11 月 Ministry of Health states: intensive care.
eyes in Huangxue Tao Zou should have that the hospital could only be treated in accordance with the principle of voluntary patients.
the past few years, Huang collected a large number of similar cases across the country found that due to China's the first for newly diagnosed, if the judge had psychiatric symptoms, were admitted; some do not for newly diagnosed, admitted to hospital as long as the relatives of commission, to be admitted to observe the force.
It is in the latter case, December 20, 2005 around 11 o'clock at night, after an argument with his wife some, Guangzhou businessman He Jinrong not been diagnosed, he was commissioned by his wife forced Guangzhou Brain Hospital admitted.
lack of self-correcting system, if the hospital that treated
rich areas 二沙岛, buy a mansion, a net worth of millions.
the hospital records, having an affair, his wife scolded for no reason, playing the wife hh newspaper, his wife Chen Yanfang led the two men came in, he was punched first, then be reined in his neck, and then be chained. admitted to the hospital, doctors Wu Zejun tied to the bed He Jinrong of a dialogue first visit, and made a diagnosis of record.
but Wuze Jun newly diagnosed concluded that , the mother, brother and other relatives of the phone available to Wuze Jun, Wu to help him in touch with family night, family members rushed to the hospital then, but the hospital asking them to provide evidence of documentary evidence of kinship. The next day, they are all in the police station for good procedures, the hospital's attitude changed. hospital said only the first guardian, that He Jinrong wife can apply for his discharge procedures.
the third day, the hospital turn any diagnosis of . Since then, He Jinrong be treated as a mental patient, treated in the hospital for a month.
this month, the company's financial officer to the hospital every day, He Jinrong across the gates to handle its affairs. < br> treated as mental patients. 21, the hospital where the mother and other family members agreed, for his discharge procedures.
, the same hospital, management, how this confusion? notice to the court hearing that his wife had sued him, asked for a divorce.
2006 年 5 31, He Jinrong court to Liwan, Guangzhou Brain Hospital. Hospital, Zhong Qi attorney argued that He Jinrong reflects the hospital where his wife of 20 years, history of mental illness and require hospital treatment the hospital against him in the hope that he received timely treatment, so the hospital will He Jinrong observation and treatment in hospital, did not violate the law. Because He Jinrong resistance, care workers only Use the
He Jinrong its attorney Xie Jiandong found that the various practices of the hospital are admitted to programs prove their serious problems. such as records of their medical records on home, question mark shows that the hospital has not confirmed his final mental illness.
even more absurd is that the court later, the hospital attorney submitted to the court He Jinrong medical records, comparing their discharge from any copies of medical records found After his discharge, the hospital made many of its records tampered with, such as temporary doctor's advice alone, there are four drugs is a circle surrounding a hospital, and indicate the He Jinrong discharged from the hospital after the first day of their hospital records, added two amendments to diagnosis: tampering with medical records would it? symptoms of mental illness need to force admitted, and let the intrinsic motivation wrong.
The Brain Hospital, Guangzhou, Zhong Qi, said the attorney, the other is a mental patient, whether admitted, their families information provided is very important. and psychiatric diagnosis, one month observation period, so the needs of patients admitted to the diagnosis.
dangerous ; to pay for those responsible for the woke up, she heard the nurse said: nurse said: > nurse verification, then came back and said: Li, we do not mistake, you are sent in your family, you got sick, you do not take medicine, you have injected your own choice! , no other person can not meet Zou Yijun. the hospital sent someone to her 24-hour personal way to meet people in a mental hospital is very common. has offered a 24-hour special care requirements. , ate a cold shoulder. back before the crash, Zou Zou Yi Chih sister were both heard, said her sister Zou Wan are sent to a mental hospital must, therefore, met with her lawyer Huang Xuetao earlier signed a power of attorney, delegate Huang for her loss of freedom in the case of an agent or lawyer.
yellow power of attorney presented to the hospital, but the hospital denied that Chow should have admitted.
at being rejected, Huang Xuetao alarm, Guangzhou Baiyun District Yongping the police station after the police arrived, the hospital admitted were admitted Zou Yi, but the police in the grounds of medical dispute, the inconvenience involved.
next day, Zou Zou's sister Chih requirements are visiting from Beijing, came to the hospital, but hospitals in the same reason to refuse: pressure, organizational expert consultation, diagnosed as manic depression, is and others, quietly Zou should have picked up from the Guangzhou Baiyun mental hospital, into the Lake Hospital, Zhongshan Port, Zhongshan City, which is a psychiatric hospital.
Since then, Zou should have disappeared. In order to find her whereabouts, Huang Xuetao try to media complaints , letters, etc. methods, but to no avail.
Huang Xuetao also family members know her whereabouts, so do not tell anyone.
Police also believe that it is doctor-patient relationship, suggested that she complained to the administrative departments .2006 December 6, yellow to the Health Department of Guangdong Province issued an emergency report, but did not answered.
same year by the end of December, Huang had to sue Zou Yijun, a request the court to both the contractual relationship, and pay their travel expenses, I hope the judicial power of the Chow should have reached court. but because the family do not match, the court can not be hearing notice Zou should have served.
Brain Hospital, Guangzhou, also in accordance with the commission He Jinrong wife Chen Yanfang not let any go to the hospital to visit other relatives and friends.
Huangxue Tao said, in reality, the hospital during treatment, only those responsible for governing the practice of sending is practice. most of the mental hospital refused to treat the person and sent to know who sent the dispute between, and only sent to treat the person responsible, which is responsible only to send the status of governance, Professor of Law, National School of Administration expressed concern Yang Xiaojun.
his view, no one has the right to force mental patients sent to hospital for suspected diagnosis and treatment. . statement, rather a lack of fairness, too rash. loss of a medical reason
2006 年 10 26 to January 26, 2007, Zou should have accompanied her mother in Lake Port, Zhongshan Hospital, the mental status of a patient to receive a full three months of treatment.
but was regarded as
after discharge, Zou should get rid of the mother were close, The attorney .3 2 March at 9 am, the case in Guangzhou Baiyun People's Court, the judge admitted the review focuses on the motives and procedures for mandatory, rather than struggle really sick.
Zou Yijun from the rescue, He Jinrong case to the agent, Zou Yijun case, and admitted to the Chinese system of mental patients, Huang Xuetao that the existing system of mental patients were treated, so feel insecure, it has become citizens of a medical reason for the loss of personal freedom, the rights of citizens with to a serious threat.
2005 年 4 月 11 morning, Zhang Yueying a hospital because of drug problems with a fight, the doctors called the First Affiliated Hospital of Jinan University, said Zhang Yueying mentally ill, Jinan University, the First Affiliated the hospital without notifying the case of Zhang's family, send an ambulance pulled the sheets to force the hospital to psychiatric treatment more than a month. hospital admission nor the families of the signature sheets.
2005 年 7 16, Zhang First Affiliated Hospital of Jinan University was the second time forced from their homes and got me admitted to hospital for nearly 2 months.
2006, the Guangzhou Tianhe court that a voluntary civil activities should follow the principle of equity, civil rights and interests of citizens legal protection, any organization or individual shall not be violated. Therefore, the decree return all hospital medical expenses, and 10,000 yuan compensation for mental damages, lost income, costs 5,849 yuan.
occurred in recent years, but Huang Xuetao collected dozens around the country similar cases found in favor of those few. she was concerned that the system of mental patients admitted to a certain extent, become a host, or special means of resolving disputes.
such as the Beijing News December 8, 2008 report, Shandong Thai Farmers Sun Wu went to Beijing to petition law, the government recaptured by the local mental institution, compulsory admitted more than 20 days after the petition is no longer a guarantee signed before being released. Beijing News survey found that in Xintai, as petitioners was taken to a mental hospital who is not an individual. local government explained that the petition tremendous pressure, if there leapfrog petition will be punished by their superiors.
such practices have been supported by some scholars. Peking University Law School Professor Sun Dongdong previously accepted media interview, said: Now, in many events in the petition, there are many cases of mental patients, but also a lot. If a person showed irritability, tendencies and so harmful to the mental health sector to identify and treat is beyond reproach, that is not the focus of similar litigation in this case there is no mental problems, but mental infringement problems, because only the patient a threat to public order, threatening the personal safety of others, or hurt themselves and so when it can force admitted; as long as the patient is not suspected threat to the safety of others, whether treatment is voluntary individual behavior, others can be persuaded to treatment, but not mandatory. Therefore, the hospital admitted free to enforce is a violation of personal freedom of citizens.
3 月 2 am, in the People's Court of Guangzhou Baiyun court, has been a monk all Zou Yi said that she had secular disputes should not be entangled, but the case hit the public welfare, not to investigate who is responsible, but to Purdue beings, if the existing system is not admitted to psychiatric abolished, exposure to Shenzhen, there is still a strong sense of insecurity.

family framed the story, so the mental hospital?
Zou Yijun case, He Jinrong case is formed, and the bad blood between family members about.
He Jinrong long suspected his wife was having an affair. He said that he printed his wife's phone call records and found that she was often late at night long with the same phone call, his friend saw her often, and a teenager younger than her man together.
He Jinrong said he and his wife frank trench through, a divorce can be normal and part of the property given to her. , the wife of unusual behavior, He Jinrong judge, he was sent to a mental hospital is the wife of the trap.
and Zou should have before being sent to a mental hospital, and family relations were also tense.
her father in 2005 before his death, he established an oral will, will inherit a property to Zou Yijun, because Zou Yijun brother and two sisters each married, and older sister and brother are civil servants, high income, are sister Chih Chow, MD, graduated in Beijing became a doctor.
But Zou mother thought that, as a daughter, Zou should not inherit his father's estate, after many arguments, she should have written Zou forced to give up the inheritance of the guarantee.
father died, were also affected by Yi Zou Divorces .2006 September, she obtained a divorce by agreement, 30 million divorce compensation, ex-husband will approach 10 million in cash to the Zou Yijun, another 20 million into the account of its big sister, but not transferred to her sister , but to the Zou mother. Zou Yijun, Buddha, founder of a Buddhist site, but also to religious identity, help others rights. Therefore, Zou mother insists on the escrow money. not to be understood Zou Yijun, and his family had many a heated argument.
Zou should have said, these are the family will cause her to a mental hospital.
views clash < br> In the event of a lot of petitions, there are many cases of mental patients, but also a lot. If a person showed irritability, tendencies and so harmful to the mental health sector to the identification and treatment is beyond reproach, ; not identified by health authorities and procedures, how to determine what he is not sick? As long as patients suspected of threatening the safety of others is not whether the treatment is voluntary acts of individuals.
mental patients admitted to the existing system, to feel insecure, it has become citizens of a medical reason for the loss of personal freedom, civil rights pose a serious threat.
mmm Shenzhen Lawyers Huang Xuetao

Flew Over the Cuckoo reporter Bao Xiaodong Zou mm after the strange case should be admitted to the program are subject to review
of the court: Southern Weekend reporter He Haining, interns Wen Hailing from the bottom of the Guangzhou
2009-03-18 22:30:46
Source: Southern Weekend news
Laiwu
mental patient accused of sudden death in psychiatric mental hospital psychiatrist Why? suspected of being mentally cage farmers in Jiangxi Who will help the rural five-year prison psychiatric groups only admitted opinions ; specification admitted behavior.
and Zou should have said that she does is public interest litigation, to make normal people from being admitted to the fear.
mentally ill, was admitted to the hospital to force. 3 months.
hearing, Huang Xuetao prepared a lot of information, should Zou should have investigated whether the mentally ill and lawyers debate the court, but did not come in handy. This makes her a very pleasant surprise. past experience, such cases will entangled in the .
trial .3 years ago, in a family quarrel, his wife commissioned the Guangzhou Brain Hospital forced the husband admitted.
recent years, disputes in such cases frequently made public. According to the China Center for Disease Control and Prevention of Mental Health conservative estimate of the center, China all kinds of mental illness more than 1 million people. of which about 16 million critically ill patients.
Zou Yijun case highlights the great value of justice.
admitted to the court proceedings by the judge investigating
no investigation illness. Huangxue Tao that this transfer of many psychiatric activists are pursuing justice: 2 points. the defendant and the only hospital on behalf of all family members should Zou attorney present. collegial panel three judges arrived at the scene, forensic investigations accounted for most of the time.
Huang Xuetao memories, the judge announced the beginning of the review: First, are sent to rule Zou Yi motives and causes; second whether the process of the families of entrust compliant treated, treated process are whether the plaintiff should have Zou consequences of the damage.
gallery, mainly journalists, lawyers Deng Huaming also present. He has handled similar cases: 2000 , a secondary school teacher in Guangzhou were sent to a psychiatric hospital where the secondary force, when the case is lost. that teachers have been sued 3 times within 5 years. personal freedom. Zou should have received a very long time to speak. Denghua Ming is desirable that: fine, for example, pulled her down from the car people did not wear police uniforms, there is no reason to produce work permits and instructions. > Zou told, October 21, 2006, Shenzhen. the big brother to drive, Zou Yi are ready to go to his father grave, suddenly seized by several men. the way for a car. struggle for help are not valid. she knew when already in Guangzhou Baiyun mental hospital. followed by strong drugs, in a coma for 3 days.
her family and uncompromising, the former that the family is to hold her a divorce over two hundred thousand yuan compensation The latter were considered to be ill advised to the Zou.
Huang Xuetao that the judge's question is key:
admitted to the hospital representative said in done before the initial diagnosis. there is no written record of the judge asked. The hospital representative said > representative of the hospital, said in an interview Zoulin Feng, Zou Yijun's mother, brother and sister had consulted twice, commission sent a car to Shenzhen to receive Zou Yijun.
need door to door, and among them 20-30% need to adopt the means of force. mania legitimate rights and interests. br> interviewed by the media one after another. Buddhist Converting wearing color was xuan. is forced admitted, she has been vegetarian, do Buddhist culture sites. Now, she retreats .3 mainly in Beijing January 9, she was going to Hunan, and an invitation to her past as an abbot of the temple.
Now, Zou Yi are not alone in Shenzhen and neighboring cities, the streets, she was subconsciously looking for people who are familiar companions. she said, , she felt free.
According to Zou Yijun introduction, admission, she would be on their own. even though she had to do the preventive measures, commissioned Huang Xuetao necessary rights. but if not Chow should have stolen a telephone call for help, Huang Xuetao also do not know where the person commissioned.
start Huang Xuetao mental hospital for no such person in the clouds, as Zou registration, a pseudonym used by family members. She sent the letter even to the hospital: most is, who sent to whom we came. hospitals under contract with the family's. May not show, do not pay agency fees. the purpose of service of summons is to use coercion group, to find Zou Yijun. this is still valid.
people, how to protect his rights. species. The former refers to a threat to themselves or if the parties to the safety of others shall be promptly constraints. then as soon as possible according to medical diagnosis, the court found that in order to deprive him of his liberty.
coercive relief is admitted, the parties do not hurt themselves or others, but has lost some ability to take care of themselves, regardless of voluntary hospitalization, involuntary experience who want to force admitted, by the stakeholders to submit to the court medical diagnosis, identify the party's civil capacity, and then start custody in court power process, from spouses, family members, is responsible for care of adult children and other parties.
Huang Xuetao think the key lies, the parties shall have the right to dissent and the right to a lawyer. hospitalization, the patient should have the right to communicate with the outside world.
This cumbersome statutory procedures have not practiced. comprehensive interview expert advice, because this program is not actually feasible, but mandatory psychiatric patients admitted to a complex medical problems, not only justice can be resolved. families of all that. constraints Hospital, this is the case, we may be forced every citizen to the hospital. , there are security risks, then each of us can not be free from fear, may be tied to the mental hospital